Muskegon Heights students on possible closure: "We are not a failing school."
Students in Muskegon Heights are very familiar with uncertainty. They’ve been threatened with school closure many times over the past several years—first because of finances, now because of failing test scores.
Muskegon Heights Academy high school is one of the 38 schools the state School Reform Office says could close by the end of year if some kind of turnaround plan isn’t put in place.
For this week’s State of Opportunity, Julieaunna Clark and Antonio Thomas, two high school students from Muskegon Heights, interview each other about the fate of their school. What follows is an edited transcript of their conversation. We’ll start with Julieaunna and the now infamous letter the state sent to their school back in January.
JULIEAUNNA CLARK: Ok, I will start with a question for Antonio. How did your parents react to the situation of what’s going on with the school and everything?
ANTONIO THOMAS: My dad first got the letter. It was more of 'is this real or is this something that is just coming to us just to scare people away from the school?' Because my dad knows, he would hate for a school like this to shut down because most kids wouldn’t have the opportunities that we have now because of the fact: where would they be, what school would they kind of transition to and still get that home feeling that they have here at Muskegon Heights?
...I swear this school is the most talented school here. I mean, test scores may not show it, but if you walk up in here, you will have a friend the moment you walk through those doors.
JC: This school is probably one of the most family-oriented schools anywhere around in Michigan. I swear this school is the most talented school here. I mean test scores may not show it, but if you walk up in here, you will have a friend the moment you walk through those doors. You will have someone ‘I’ve got your back if you do something wrong. I’m a pick you up but I’mma tell you right from wrong.’ You have someone like that in the school, and I don’t feel like I can get that from anywhere else.
AT: Well, my question for you is: what do you think about when people say Muskegon Heights is a failing school?
JC: We are not a failing school. We have talented, intelligent people that wander these halls. And I just wish that one day people would just walk through these halls and see how magnificent these kids are because we have [future] doctors, future lawyers, we have it all here, just like any other school has. I mean, we may have under-performed in tests a couple times, but right now we have kids who actually have life behind them, who have struggles. And I see us as a high-performing school to have to handle stuff at such a young age. We are kids who have to handle a struggle and maintain and handle our business at the same time. So, yeah.
...we have kids who actually have life behind them, who have struggles, and I see us as a high performing school to have to handle stuff at such a young age.
AT: Well, my last question is how: how confident are you in our school? And how confident are you that it’s gonna be still standing?
JC: I’m very confident ‘cause we’ve had our school about ready to close four or five times, and this...this school ain’t closing. They really gonna have to knock down these doors to close this school because you know we gonna have students sitting there waiting, be like, this school ain't going nowhere. It’s just hard to take the heart of the community away. It’s like telling somebody to stop breathing air. And I’m beyond confident because you’re not taking the air away from me. You're not taking away my paradise, my place where I’m comfortable. This school has to stay open. It’s got to stay open.
AT: Well, you’re right on that. This school is like a tradition. You keep it here, you keep it running, oiled because at the end of the day there’s still great things in the building. You just have to come for yourself and look.